Symphonies No. 94, 104, & Ouvertuere Acide e Galatea

Beginning his survey of the Haydn with two of the composer's most popular works, conductor Fey and the Heidelburg Symphony score big, with readings possessing: "…superb craftsmanship… tip-top clarity and noblity, and "let's-do-it!" drama. His handling of the flow, the ups and downs of Haydn's propulsive forces, the interruptions to the quiet sections of the 104th's middle movements - are simply outstanding. The producers have even timed the pauses between each movement to perfection - really, just listen to the symphony and you'll see." The Flying Inkpot

"This CD marks the beginning of a new complete cycle of Joseph Haydn symphonies, to be achieved in 2009 for the 200th anniversary of the composer's death. And if the same qualitative level is maintained throughout this 10-year span, it's going to be a wonderful achievement. Thomas Fey has studied with Nikolaus Harnoncourt, and he approaches this music with the same uncompromising attitude of his teacher. Tempos are on the swift side and dynamic contrasts are extreme but never artificial. The balance is just perfect, thanks to the use of brass and timpani on period instruments, which allows the "modern" strings (played without vibrato) and woodwinds to come out very naturally. But there is more in these recordings than just authenticity. In every piece Fey uncovers the very essence of Haydn, his unpredictable humor as well as his moments of abandon and melancholy. With its sharp-edged but flexible playing, the Heidelberger Sinfoniker reveals itself to be the perfect ensemble to convey the nuances of Haydn's boundless imagination. This major enterprise benefits from a panoramic recording, at once transparent and coherent. If you like Haydn, don't miss this one. If you still don't know if you like Haydn, give it a try and be converted."
(ClassicsToday 10/10)