[ Naxos / CD ]
Release Date: Monday 5 June 2000
This item is currently out of stock. It may take 6 or more weeks to obtain from when you place your order as this is a specialist product.
"Idil Biret's playing seems perfunctory in the opening sections but most able in the final movements...slightly mechanical, never quite expressing either the grandness of the first movement or the poetry of the slow movement, but she does playfully dance about in the closing part. The orchestral accompaniment can range from burdensomely obscure to moodily transparent, depending I suppose, on the mood of the engineers. I found the accompanying Schumann piano work closer to my liking, being more concisely treated as well as striking a better balance between orchestra and soloist. At a low bargain price, this Brahms issue may seem a bargain." Sensible Sound
"The two Schumann works are fine bonuses, both rendered with the same commitment and insight from soloist and orchestra. In the end, one must assess all these performances as quite extraordinary and fully competitive with the best. Sound is good, if a bit boomy in the Brahms First. At Naxos's prices potential buyers can hardly go wrong." ClassicalNet